SANTA MONICA, Los Angeles County — November 12, 2026. One of California's longest-running legal disputes over local representation has taken a dramatic turn. A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge has granted Santa Monica's motion to dismiss a lawsuit challenging the city's citywide, at-large City Council elections. Residents associated with the Pico Neighborhood Association and plaintiff Maria Loya have argued for years that the system dilutes Latino voting influence. City lawyers reject the claim that its election structure violates governing equal-protection requirements. Attorneys for the plaintiffs say they intend to challenge the new decision. A ruling dismissing the case is not necessarily the last step of the appeals process.

What happened in court

The Santa Monica Daily Press reported November 7 that Judge Daniel M. Crowley granted the city's motion for judgment on the pleadings and directed lawyers to prepare a written order. The Lookout reported November 10 that plaintiffs' lawyer Kevin Shenkman planned to appeal, while the formal proposed order still required judicial signature at the time of reporting. Some accounts differ in how they date the oral ruling; California58 is not treating an unsworn summary as a certified docket entry.

Why district elections matter

Santa Monica currently elects its council members across the whole city. The plaintiffs say the system prevents Latino voters concentrated in the Pico neighborhood from electing their preferred representatives. The city argues that the legal record does not establish discriminatory intent under the federal constitutional framework it says applies. These are different legal theories, not an objective evaluation of any resident's political preferences. The case concerns the California Voting Rights Act (CVRA) and the interaction between state standards and newer federal equal-protection precedents.

How the case reached this point

Filed in 2016, the suit produced a 2019 trial judgment favoring district elections, a 2020 appellate reversal and a 2023 California Supreme Court decision that rejected part of the appellate court's reasoning and sent the matter back. City attorneys cited the U.S. Supreme Court's 2026 decision in Louisiana v. Callais in seeking dismissal. The plaintiffs dispute its relevance to California law, arguing the state statute focuses on discriminatory effects rather than an intent requirement. No California58 headline should describe the contested legal question as fully settled for all cities by this one ruling.

What readers should track

  1. When will a signed written judgment be entered and what precise grounds will it state?
  2. Will plaintiffs file a notice of appeal, and what deadlines apply?
  3. Will the city's electoral system change, or will citywide elections continue while litigation proceeds?
  4. What public costs, including outside counsel fees, can the city document over the life of the litigation?
  5. What are residents' options for commenting on representation without turning this legal story into advocacy for a particular candidate?

Santa Monica News will follow the next court filing and fairly attribute the city and plaintiffs' positions. Readers may submit court documents or verifiable corrections at Santa Monica News. No relevant authenticated YouTube recording of the latest court ruling was established, so this story uses linked source documents rather than a generic legal-news video.

Sources: Santa Monica Daily Press, Nov. 7; The Lookout, Nov. 10, including plaintiff counsel's response.

Help Santa Monica News grow Help strengthen reporting on Santa Monica: community voices, important decisions and local life.
Support Santa Monica News

Choose how to support Santa Monica News:

Credit / Debit Card via Stripe

Choose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.

Continue with PayPal Continue with Zelle

Zelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.

Optional reader support. When possible, add “Santa Monica News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.

Santa Monica News — Your Community Newspaper

Have a correction, news tip, local announcement, or story to submit? Contact our editorial team. All submissions are reviewed before publication.

Contact the Santa Monica News newsroom →

More from Santa Monica News

Visit Santa Monica News →

COMMUNITY

Comments

Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.